We discuss and evaluate metasearch engines.
Class held on 12/01/2008. Student notes are available on this page. Possible questions are available on this page.
Class structure
- Go through “At beginning of class” information
- Go through highlights of some of the amazing search tools that are available.
- Work on exercises
At beginning of class
- Blogs — I have graded a bunch.
- ummmm: “definately”? “it's” vs. “its”
- Rest of the semester:
- 12/03: Yahoo
- same protocol for the visit
- 12/08: Semester summary, project unveiling
- 12/03: Yahoo
- You still need to post blog entries that received a “10”
- Go over any other announcements you might have missed since last class.
- Check the start page for any blogs you might be interested in that you might have missed.
My notes
The search community has a tool called a meta-search engine. These tools derive their functionality from other search engines. A complicating factor is that there are two very different types of tools that are called meta-search engines. The search community does not recognize these subtypes, but they are very real and quite significant:
- Integrated search for multiple search engines
- the meta-search engine uses an algorithm to combine the results from multiple search engines into one result list
- Unified interface for separate search engines
- the meta-search engine provides a single interface, enabling easy and quick switching between the results of different search engines
These are very different tools. In the first case, the functionality provided by the meta-search engine revolves around an informed method of combining the results of multiple search engines, while in the second case the functionality is simply based on providing a unified interface while simply passing through the results from one external search engine at a time.
Resources
Integrated search for multiple search engines
- Search.com (review, help, search tips)
- example: carbon trading (web), carbon trading (images), carbon trading (reference)
- other: top searches
- Features
- Integrates Google, Ask, MSN, DMOZ
- Separate tabs for Web, Images, Video, Reference (Wikipedia), Directory, Downloads, Shopping, People, Games, Music, Entertainment, News
- Info.com (about, review)
- examples: carbon trading (web), carbon trading (images), carbon trading (reference)
- other: separate columns for Web results & sponsored results
- Features
- Integrates Google, Yahoo, Live, Ask, About
- Separate tabs for Web, Research, News, Images, Video, Health, Shop, Classifieds, Flights, Jobs, Hotels, Movies, Audio, Yellow Pages, White Pages, Webmail
- ixQuick (about, review)
- examples: cannot link directly to results
- other: explicit aggregation (with stars), refinement of results with user input
- Features
- Integrates All the Web, Ask, EntireWeb, Exalead, Gigablast, MSN, NBC, Open Directory, Qkport, Wikipedia, Winzy, Yahoo
- Separate tabs for Web, International phone directory, Video, Pictures
- Mamma (about, help, review)
- examples: carbon trading (web)
- other: refine your search
- Features
- Integrates Open Directory, Business.com, About.com, Ask, Gigablast, Wisenut, EntireWeb
- Separate tabs for Web, Videos, Jobs, Shop, Yellow Pages, White Pages
- Clusty (about, review)
- examples: advanced search form, carbon trading (advanced search results), carbon trading (web), carbon trading (images), carbon trading (wikipedia)
- other: metasearch with clustering (description of their clustering technology)
- Features
- Integrates Ask, Live, others
- Separate tabs for Web, News, Images, Wikipedia, Blogs, Jobs, Shopping, Gov, Labs
- DogPile (about, review)
- examples: carbon trading (web), carbon trading (images)
- other: favorite fetches (on home page), related searches
- Features
- Integrates Google, Yahoo, Live, Ask
- Separate tabs for Web, Images, Audio, Video, News, Yellow Pages, White Pages
- ShoppingVale — a metasearch engine for shopping
- Others
Unified interface for separate search engines
- Soovle (click "secrets" in upper right)
- other: top searches,
- automatic refinement of search in multiple search engines in real time (really cool)
- Be sure to hit the right arrow key after you have entered a search (but before pressing enter)
- Features
- Separate searches for Google, Yahoo, Ask, Wikipedia, Amazon, Answers.com, YouTube
- Just Web search
- other: top searches,
- FastEagle
- other: a "tools" tab
- Features
- Separate searches for about a dozen Web sites in each category
- Separate tabs for Home (Web), News, Business, Tech, Lifestyle, Interests, Fun, Video, Music
- Kedrix (review)
- Features
- Separate searches for Google, Yahoo, Live, Ask
- Just Web search
- Features
- Search.IO
- other: latest searches
- Features
- Separate searches for 8-10 sites in each category
- Separate tabs for Audio, Blogs, Books, CSS Galleries, Fonts, Images, Jobs, Lyrics, News, People, Recipes, Search Engines, Social Bookmarks, Stock Photos, Torrents, Tutorials, Videos, Web 2.0 Sites
- Joongel (review)
- Features
- Integrates the "10 leading Websites" in each category
- Separate tabs for General Search, Images, Music, Videos, Shopping, Social, Q&A, Health, Torrents, Gossip
- Features
- Zuula (about, help)
- other: tracks recent searches
- Features
- Separate searches for Google, Yahoo, Live, Gigablast, Exalead, Alexa, Entireweb, Mahalo, Wikia, Visvo
- Separate tabs for Web, Images, Video, News, Blog, Jobs
- IntelWays
- other:
- Features
- Separate searches for 10-20 web sites per category
- Separate tabs for General, Images, Video, News, Social, Files, Reference, Academic, Business, Tech, Shop
- LeapFish (about, review)
- Features
- Separate searches for Google, Yahoo, MSN
- Separate tabs for Web, News, Answers, Videos, Images, Shopping, Blogs
- Features